Should People With High Incomes Be Allowed To Shop At Thrift Stores?

I like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal. In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there…

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Last Updated: January 27, 2025

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you decide to make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. See my disclosure for more info.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for "poor people." Who should be allowed to shop at thrift stores? #thriftstores #savemoney #moneysavingtipsI like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal.

In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there for many years, starting as a sales associate and eventually becoming a manager. Due to working for several years at a secondhand shop, I love a good deal, and it’s still hard for me to pay full price for clothing. We saw lots of high-quality clothing and brand name accessories coming in and being sold for a fraction of the price you would see at a traditional retail store.

Buying secondhand doesn’t just save you a ton of money, it prevents waste and lessens the number of things piling up in landfills.

I think we are all aware that we are throwing things into landfills at alarming rates, and shopping secondhand can be one of many ways to make a difference.

However, that’s not how some people see shopping at thrift stores, especially if you have a high income.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for “poor people.”

I have been told that by shopping at a thrift store, I am taking items that people with less money could have bought and used.

I’ve also heard that people who shop at thrift stores in order to flip items for a higher profit are “evil.”

Other comments I’ve heard about shopping at thrift stores include (these are all direct quotes):

  • “Why donate if it’s not going to poor people?”
  • “A person isn’t actually wealthy if they shop at Goodwill.”
  • “Shopping at thrift stores is for people who can’t afford clothes.”
  • “The wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money. They should leave it for the less fortunate.”

Personally, I believe that thrift stores and discounts are for anyone to use. Of course, everyone is allowed to have their own opinion, but I would bet that those people don’t really understand the positives of purchasing secondhand or the missions that non-profit secondhand stores have.

Related content:

As you can see from the tweet below, my question generated a lot of conversation – from both sides even!

Here is why I believe anyone should be allowed to shop at thrift stores.

 

Everyone is allowed to save money.

Seriously, every single person should be able to save money if they want. Everyone, period.

Do I need to say it again?

People who think that the wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money are just nuts in my opinion.

Plus, as you’ll read below, thrift stores serve many other purposes, such as preventing an overwhelming amount of waste clogging landfills and furthering a thrift store’s mission to help charities and their community.

Thrift stores are usually bursting at the seams with new things to put out, meaning there is no shortage of things to buy.

Thrift stores can save a person a lot of money, and who is to say who can and cannot save money?

The wealthy are wealthy for a reason- many of them know how to manage their money correctly. And, this may include shopping at thrift stores and using discounts/coupons. Many look for realistic ways to save money because they don’t like to waste money if they can prevent it.

After all, you’ll never be wealthy if you spend it all.

There are many ways to save money and grow your wealth, and shopping secondhand can be a small step in gaining financial freedom.

Related content: Why You Should Spend Like A Millionaire- The Frugal and Smart Money Habits of Millionaires

 

It’s environmentally responsible to shop at thrift stores.

Thrift stores usually have an overwhelming number of things. It’s not like you are going to buy 100% of the items in the store – they have thousands upon thousands of items to sell.

When you purchase something secondhand, you are keeping one more item out of a landfill.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, 15.1 million tons of textile waste was product in 2013, with around 85% of that going to landfills.

And, according to the Huffington Post, Americans, on average, throw away 70 pounds of clothing each year.

According to Down To Earth Materials, the estimated decomposition time for clothing and other items are:

  • Leather shoes: 25-40 years
  • Nylon clothes: 30-40 years
  • Cotton: 1-5 months
  • Tin can: around 50 years
  • Plastic bottles: 70-450 years

As you can see, the clothing we wear and other household items we use can have a big environmental impact. By purchasing secondhand clothing and items, we can lower the amount of waste we put into landfills and help the environment well into the future.

With more people shopping at thrift stores, there are even more items that are getting a second “life” and even fewer items ending up in landfills.

Can you just imagine how crazy landfills would be if certain people weren’t allowed to shop at thrift stores? There would be so much trash everywhere!

Related: How Thrift Store Reselling Is Good For The Environment And How To Do It

 

There’s enough for everyone at a thrift store.

For the most part, buying a t-shirt at Goodwill or Salvation Army isn’t going to negatively impact anyone – they have plenty of everything there. In some places, they are actually turning away donations because they have TOO MUCH STUFF.

When we donated about 99% of our belongings to move into the RV, we took a lot of our things to thrift stores, but, surprisingly, a lot of our belongings were rejected because they had too much stuff or too many of a specific item. We actually had to hunt for places that would take some of our stuff.

Most of the things that are sold at thrift shops aren’t going to be life or death for anyone – it’s just stuff, which may be hard for many people to realize now, but it is the truth.

There is plenty for everyone and thrift stores won’t be running out of basic household items and clothing anytime soon.

So, the belief that “rich people are taking away items from the less fortunate” is not realistic – because there’s plenty of stuff for everyone. Like I said, thrift stores are bursting with so much stuff that they are turning donations away!

 

Your money is helping the thrift store’s mission.

Thrift stores like Goodwill and Salvation Army exist so that they can make money and put that money towards the charities they support.

So, more people shopping at these thrift stores can help further their mission of helping the community.

For example, with the money Goodwill makes through selling items at its stores and through donations, they were able to place more than 313,000 people into employment in just 2016. It’s possible that if you took away some of their customer base, they may not have been able to help as many people. They even state on their website:

“When you donate your new and gently used items to Goodwill®, we sell them in our stores or on our online auction site and use the revenue generated to fund valuable employment training and job placement services for people in your community.”

For many non-profit thrift stores, their mission actually isn’t to solely sell clothes at low prices. Instead, their mission is to further improve the community and the people in it. To do that, they need funds, and they raise funds by selling donated items.

So, the more people who shop at these stores (including people who can afford regularly priced stuff) actually help them further their mission.

So, what do you think? Do you think that thrift stores and discounts shouldn’t be used by people who can afford otherwise?


Filed under:

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Author: Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Hey! I’m Michelle Schroeder-Gardner and I am the founder of Making Sense of Cents. I’m passionate about all things personal finance, side hustles, making extra money, and online businesses. I have been featured in major publications such as Forbes, CNBC, Time, and Business Insider. Learn more here.

Like this article?

Join the Conversation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. SmallIvy

    Thrift stores don’t sell at the prices they do in order to help out the poor, they sell the clothes for the price people will pay. You can take a brand new outfit that cost $30 in the stores, tags attached, and be lucky to get fifty cents for it at a yard sale. Used clothes just don’t sell for much.

  2. DNN

    Shopping at thrift stores is always a good thing and here’s why. Though you may not find something for yourself, you might find something peculiar and want to re-sell it online for a quick turnaround side hustle profit. This method of visiting thrift stores and reselling online has made many people to day a “side hustle millionaire.” So yes, in my opinion I agree it’s okay for existing “side hustle millionaires” to shop at thrift stores! 🙂

  3. A.Roddy

    Money is not what makes a person. The jealousy card is tiresome.

  4. Gabriella

    I have never heard anyone in my life, make a moral argument against shopping at a thrift store! Sorry you had to experience that!

    Buying second hand is great for the environment too!

  5. Pamela

    I can’t tell you how many times clients would say those same things to me when I was managing a consignment store. It was like a double-standard, it was no problem for them to consign and make money off their clothing, but they would never shop there themselves as it was for “lesser people” than them. I am considered lower-middle class income, I am very thrifty and have a nice small home, fully decorated and I have nice things to wear. You’d never know to look at me that nothing I have is new and I paid a fraction of the retail for it. I’m a proud thrifter!

  6. Aidbdiandjdk

    Thankyou. My mom doesn’t let me thrift shop because she said “you dont shop from where you donate” and its “philosophically wrong.” I’m definitely going to use this to help convince her otherwise.

  7. Jose

    Should poor people be allowed to buy products in high end stores? The question is silly. Of course anyone can shop wherever they want. Morality doesn’t equal legality and this is free country.

  8. Linda

    My home is paid for, and I drive a brand new car. I proudly shop at thrift, Goodwill, Salvation Army Store wherever I can find a great deal. I found a designer coat for 7 bucks the other day. It just makes GOOD SENSE. I can afford new and expensive when I want to, but thrift shopping is the bomb. I love it.

  9. eat the rich

    great article! this totally makes me feel better being an actual poor person who can literally only afford to buy cheap, mostly used, necessities but who can’t find anything that legitimately looks good because by the time i am able to make it to a thrift store (as i work three jobs) they’ve all been picked clean of the desirable shit by yuppies who don’t know what it does to someone’s self esteem when you’re forced to wear ugly crap your whole life! i’m so glad i decided to look up the consensus on this issue as i was standing in line at a good will with just two plain t-shirts and an itchy sweater!! so glad you get to pinch pennies! that must feel great, to be able to have extra left over with all you’re saving!! meanwhile i HAVE TO buy these clothes because if i don’t i am forced to make trips to the laundromat more frequently, wasting time and money i don’t have. i don’t shop here because it puts extra in my pocket. i shop here because it’s my only choice. i never have extra in my pocket. you could shop at upscale consignment stores or vintage boutiques if you really want to lower your carbon footprint. if middle class hipsters just did that, it would leave so many more options to poor people so we can actually /shop/ instead of begrudgingly pay for things that will make us feel like undesirables. people donate to the needy, for a cause, not simply to recycle. how about you leave those donations to the needy and stick to literally everything else on earth that is available to you. god forbid a poor person has a date or job interview. fuck. y’all really don’t want us to ever have anything nice. not even when it’s used. maybe think about the immediate moral consequences of your shopping habits as well as future environmental ones. but good for you! so happy you established everything is for your taking! fuck what poor people want!

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Did you even read the article? Or, do you know the mission of many of these thrift stores?

      I’m guessing this isn’t a real comment, but still.

      1. Diana

        I am sure it’s not a real comment. Employees at most thrift shops keep putting out more items throughout the day as stocks get depleted. A person can come in at any time and find a good selection. If anyone finds a store’s stock “picked over” at the end of the day, they should just go to a different thrift store.

    2. JC

      I honestly don’t believe you. I go to the thrift store sporadically and there is almost always something there.

    3. Lola Bard

      Wow! Sorry you’re so self-loathing!

    4. Nadja

      You said that you need to take more trips to the laundromat more frequently, wasting time and money. Are you seriusly saying that you buy clothes instead of washing them? That is one of the dumbest things I’ve heard. Maybe you could wash them instead and therefore save some money. Try it.

      1. emma

        oh i think she meant that if she didn’t buy the clothes available at the thrift store she would be forced to go to the laundromat more often because she wouldn’t have enough clothing to wear throughout the week otherwise. she is trying to say that she has such a small amount of clothing that she would have to consistently wash what little she has to be able to wear anything at all.

    5. Mary

      I believe this is a real comment and have felt the same way. I needed clothes for job interviews and it was really my only option. People with a lot of money go in there buying up the nice things, and I just need one decent option that looks like it fits.

      For the well off people that go thrift store shopping because it is “fashionable” and “fun”, if you aren’t at a higher priced consignment shop, consider not buying utility clothing like warm coats, suits, button down blouses, or only get a few items. You can rationalize it if it makes you feel better, but be aware other people may need those items to get by.

  10. Brig

    Actually, people with low income no longer can afford to shop at Goodwill. If it is a cup, a glass, or a plate, they all market up to $ 1.99. Clothes have also ridiculous prices. I will not ever again shop at Goodwill, nor will I donate to them or promote this store.
    BTW, Goodwill International CEO, Jim Gibbons, made $729,000 in salary and deferred compensation.
    I wonder if he is the one who ordered such huge price increase in the stores?

    1. Diana

      Try the ARC if you have it in our community. A nice plate costs 50 to 75 cents, a mug 50 cents, and near the end of the month they mark everything down to a quarter, and on the last day, to a dime. Yes there are still GOOD things left, not just at the end of the day but the end of the month. They just haven’t been found by the right buyer. We see a lot of very expensive cars parked outside, too – especially on the sale days!

  11. Joan

    I grew up in NY and my mom went to thrift stores. I was 16 when I bought my first dress at a regular store! I never felt deprived. My circumstances changed when I married and moved to Ct but having a large family and getting through some tough times I would shop at thrift stores. My four year old son was so proud to pick out a shirt for himself (2 sizes too big) he wore it proudly for two yrs!
    Now I am old. I shop for a friend in assisted living because she cannot afford much and has no one to take her shopping. If something I give her doesn’t fit she can give it away and I haven’t spent a ton of money. God bless everyone who shops at thrift stores and the people who donate to them!

  12. Diana

    Of course people with high incomes should be able to shop at thrift stores! The very idea of “not allowing” someone to shop somewhere reeks of totalitarianism. This is America. Shop where you please,

  13. Lynne

    Where I live, thrift stores receive more in donations than they can sell. Goodwill has a special store where unsold items from their other stores are given one more chance to be sold, and everything is priced by the pound.

  14. Bea

    The way I look at things, the real purposeof these nont-for-profits is creating cash from donations to support the community (either through jobs, food banks, and other community projects). Selling their inventory, whoever buys them rich or poor should be promoted so more revenue is obtained. Of course, these shops also are able to provide affordable clothing for the ones who need it and help those with higher income a source of vintage and green shopping that can help reduce waste on the planet. Donating clothes, repurposing as d reusing products, should be something highly encouraged to everyone regardless of our income. Where I live in Canada it’s not uncommon to see fashionistas trying to get the latest vintage piece from thrriftshop and they buy in bulk and often. All that money goes to charitable activities and salaries. I would say… Bring it on! Everyone should shop on thrift shops and donate as well.

  15. Kaiser soze

    if you are rich and shop at discount stores, you should be hung by the neck in the public square