Should People With High Incomes Be Allowed To Shop At Thrift Stores?

I like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal. In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there…

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Last Updated: January 27, 2025

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you decide to make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. See my disclosure for more info.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for "poor people." Who should be allowed to shop at thrift stores? #thriftstores #savemoney #moneysavingtipsI like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal.

In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there for many years, starting as a sales associate and eventually becoming a manager. Due to working for several years at a secondhand shop, I love a good deal, and it’s still hard for me to pay full price for clothing. We saw lots of high-quality clothing and brand name accessories coming in and being sold for a fraction of the price you would see at a traditional retail store.

Buying secondhand doesn’t just save you a ton of money, it prevents waste and lessens the number of things piling up in landfills.

I think we are all aware that we are throwing things into landfills at alarming rates, and shopping secondhand can be one of many ways to make a difference.

However, that’s not how some people see shopping at thrift stores, especially if you have a high income.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for “poor people.”

I have been told that by shopping at a thrift store, I am taking items that people with less money could have bought and used.

I’ve also heard that people who shop at thrift stores in order to flip items for a higher profit are “evil.”

Other comments I’ve heard about shopping at thrift stores include (these are all direct quotes):

  • “Why donate if it’s not going to poor people?”
  • “A person isn’t actually wealthy if they shop at Goodwill.”
  • “Shopping at thrift stores is for people who can’t afford clothes.”
  • “The wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money. They should leave it for the less fortunate.”

Personally, I believe that thrift stores and discounts are for anyone to use. Of course, everyone is allowed to have their own opinion, but I would bet that those people don’t really understand the positives of purchasing secondhand or the missions that non-profit secondhand stores have.

Related content:

As you can see from the tweet below, my question generated a lot of conversation – from both sides even!

Here is why I believe anyone should be allowed to shop at thrift stores.

 

Everyone is allowed to save money.

Seriously, every single person should be able to save money if they want. Everyone, period.

Do I need to say it again?

People who think that the wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money are just nuts in my opinion.

Plus, as you’ll read below, thrift stores serve many other purposes, such as preventing an overwhelming amount of waste clogging landfills and furthering a thrift store’s mission to help charities and their community.

Thrift stores are usually bursting at the seams with new things to put out, meaning there is no shortage of things to buy.

Thrift stores can save a person a lot of money, and who is to say who can and cannot save money?

The wealthy are wealthy for a reason- many of them know how to manage their money correctly. And, this may include shopping at thrift stores and using discounts/coupons. Many look for realistic ways to save money because they don’t like to waste money if they can prevent it.

After all, you’ll never be wealthy if you spend it all.

There are many ways to save money and grow your wealth, and shopping secondhand can be a small step in gaining financial freedom.

Related content: Why You Should Spend Like A Millionaire- The Frugal and Smart Money Habits of Millionaires

 

It’s environmentally responsible to shop at thrift stores.

Thrift stores usually have an overwhelming number of things. It’s not like you are going to buy 100% of the items in the store – they have thousands upon thousands of items to sell.

When you purchase something secondhand, you are keeping one more item out of a landfill.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, 15.1 million tons of textile waste was product in 2013, with around 85% of that going to landfills.

And, according to the Huffington Post, Americans, on average, throw away 70 pounds of clothing each year.

According to Down To Earth Materials, the estimated decomposition time for clothing and other items are:

  • Leather shoes: 25-40 years
  • Nylon clothes: 30-40 years
  • Cotton: 1-5 months
  • Tin can: around 50 years
  • Plastic bottles: 70-450 years

As you can see, the clothing we wear and other household items we use can have a big environmental impact. By purchasing secondhand clothing and items, we can lower the amount of waste we put into landfills and help the environment well into the future.

With more people shopping at thrift stores, there are even more items that are getting a second “life” and even fewer items ending up in landfills.

Can you just imagine how crazy landfills would be if certain people weren’t allowed to shop at thrift stores? There would be so much trash everywhere!

Related: How Thrift Store Reselling Is Good For The Environment And How To Do It

 

There’s enough for everyone at a thrift store.

For the most part, buying a t-shirt at Goodwill or Salvation Army isn’t going to negatively impact anyone – they have plenty of everything there. In some places, they are actually turning away donations because they have TOO MUCH STUFF.

When we donated about 99% of our belongings to move into the RV, we took a lot of our things to thrift stores, but, surprisingly, a lot of our belongings were rejected because they had too much stuff or too many of a specific item. We actually had to hunt for places that would take some of our stuff.

Most of the things that are sold at thrift shops aren’t going to be life or death for anyone – it’s just stuff, which may be hard for many people to realize now, but it is the truth.

There is plenty for everyone and thrift stores won’t be running out of basic household items and clothing anytime soon.

So, the belief that “rich people are taking away items from the less fortunate” is not realistic – because there’s plenty of stuff for everyone. Like I said, thrift stores are bursting with so much stuff that they are turning donations away!

 

Your money is helping the thrift store’s mission.

Thrift stores like Goodwill and Salvation Army exist so that they can make money and put that money towards the charities they support.

So, more people shopping at these thrift stores can help further their mission of helping the community.

For example, with the money Goodwill makes through selling items at its stores and through donations, they were able to place more than 313,000 people into employment in just 2016. It’s possible that if you took away some of their customer base, they may not have been able to help as many people. They even state on their website:

“When you donate your new and gently used items to Goodwill®, we sell them in our stores or on our online auction site and use the revenue generated to fund valuable employment training and job placement services for people in your community.”

For many non-profit thrift stores, their mission actually isn’t to solely sell clothes at low prices. Instead, their mission is to further improve the community and the people in it. To do that, they need funds, and they raise funds by selling donated items.

So, the more people who shop at these stores (including people who can afford regularly priced stuff) actually help them further their mission.

So, what do you think? Do you think that thrift stores and discounts shouldn’t be used by people who can afford otherwise?


Filed under:

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Author: Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Hey! I’m Michelle Schroeder-Gardner and I am the founder of Making Sense of Cents. I’m passionate about all things personal finance, side hustles, making extra money, and online businesses. I have been featured in major publications such as Forbes, CNBC, Time, and Business Insider. Learn more here.

Like this article?

Join the Conversation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Mrs. Kiwi @ KiwiAndKeweenaw.com

    Thrift stores are for everyone! If someone feels guilty shopping at a thrift shop they can always make a donation to the store!

    I definitely agree with your case for rescuing the item from the landfill, and shopping thrift stores is a great way to do that. The more clothing/items that pass through the store, the more donations they can collect.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, definitely!

  2. Accidental Fire

    Great post Michelle and I agree with your point of view. I think some of the attitude that ‘rich people shouldn’t be allowed to shop at thrift stores’ probably comes from that same segment of society that harbors hate and resentment for the rich. Unfortunately I think that segment of society has grown in recent years.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      It’s not just the rich too. Some people think that even people with a middle class income shouldn’t be allowed to shop at thrift stores like Goodwill. That’s just crazy!

      1. Erin

        There’s a huge difference in poverty , people in poverty CANNOT cover all the basics including clothes food ect .. people that are middle income and above have their financial stuff together and there is a difference between “ saving “ money being frugal and just being CHEAP .. you certainly are taking it away from a child that NEEDS it .. you are ABLE to buy used so check out consignment Craigslist kijiji Facebook groups
        How disgusting are you

        1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

          Do you honestly think that thrift stores are only for those who can afford it? You do know what the mission of most of them are, correct?

        2. Jeff

          Please do research. If a child is in need many municipalities have places like a food pantry but instead of food they have clothes that are donated and given freely. A person who works at a local thrift store told me once that only ten percent of clothing that comes in hits the floor. Why? Is what is discard soiled, has holes? No! When the racks are full and they have sorted clothes to go out they simply take clothes never even looked at and toss them. So upwards of 90 percent of what they get gets tossed and much of that is never even sorted. But, yes, a child needs it.

    2. A.Roddy

      Little late but what about the richer class resentment to the poor? i see more of that. The richer politicians have been wanting to take away from the poor like they don’t deserve any help. They get called lazy just for asking help.

      IMO I do think there should be an income limit. Maybe they would learn how it feels to be turned down. ” You see richer people born into it have no clue about earning. They have no clue about poverty. Think Paris Hilton and the Kardashians. That’s where the ‘gently’ used comes in-wear one time by someone who doesn’t get working a regular job.

  3. Jason@Simple Man Money

    Totally agree with you, Michelle. Not allowing “rich” people to shop at thrift stores would be like saying wealthy people can’t buy used cars, or check out free library books. It’s a ridiculous argument, largely perpetuated by those suffering from wealth envy.

    Perhaps the reason wealthy people stay that way is because they shop at thrift stores and buy modest vehicles.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, it is definitely a ridiculous argument!

  4. DNN

    That’s a very good question. I guess it’s safe to say rich or poor, it’s a matter of choice. The good news about shopping at thrift stores is that if a person is looking to start a business on just a few bucks or few hundred dollars to their life savings, they could start by purchasing small items out of thrift stores. Then turn around and senn them for a profit online on sites like eBaY, Etsy, Poshmark, and so on. Whether someone is rich or not, I think everyone should shop at thrift stores. You’ll find amazing bargains there. I shop there from time to time myself. 🙂

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, I agree!

  5. Nicole

    So basically the naysayers are implying that people who have money should waste it? I don’t think so. Just because someone can afford to purchase new items doesn’t require them to do so. Besides, that’s the type of mindset that gets people in financial trouble. I buy clothing from thrift stores because I like having new to me clothes without sacrificing my retirement savings goals. I get very anxious when I spend money on wants vs needs even though I currently can afford it; shopping thrift negates that anxiety. When I’m no longer into the item I donate it back to the store where I purchased it. In fact, I donate or give away most of my unwanted items because I can’t stand the idea of throwing out something that someone else could use.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, it’s definitely the mindset that can ruin a person’s finances.

      1. DNN

        Very true, Michelle. Look forward to a lengthy blog comment on your next post. Content marketing is my specialty. 🙂

  6. Pamela Webster

    Your debate reminds me of one other thing I consider when I’m shopping in thrift stores–thrift stores only exist because so many people are so wasteful.

    I feel like a bottom feeder when I realize that I was able to find a nice rain coat because someone else bought one, never wore it, and gave it away.

    Frankly, I’d rather we structure our society so everyone has the money they need to thrive and no one is wasteful.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, people can definitely be wasteful.

  7. Tina

    I started shopping at thrift stores when my husband and I were just starting out. We had just finished college and had 2 little ones. We were living on $25K (this was in 1989, so things weren’t quite as expensive as today). It was the only way I could clothe my little ones.
    Fast forward 28 years. We make substantially more money and are quite comfortable, yet, every week I am at Goodwill or other thrift store trying to find a bargain. I am sure all my years of shopping through stores helped us get in the financial position we are in now.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, exactly! Great job Tina.

  8. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

    Thanks!

  9. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

    Thank you 🙂

  10. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

    Yes, exactly!

  11. Mrs. COD

    It’s so ridiculous that people think it’s a poor person’s privilege to shop at thrift stores! As you pointed out, there are plenty of donations, so you’re certainly not taking it away from the poor. And of course, keeping frugal habits like this is one more way you keep your financial situation secure for now and the future. Now, if people like you were going to food pantries to try and get free groceries, that would be wrong. But shopping thriftily is a completely different thing! (Besides, when people with money buy cheap clothing, it frees up more of their money to donate to charitable organizations…)

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, shopping thriftily is definitely different 🙂

  12. SJ

    Who gets to decide if someone is “too wealthy” to shop at a thrift store? And what kind of constraints do they get to place on that? I would probably be considered “wealthy” by some people, and I rarely go to Goodwill anymore, mostly because it’s out of the way, and I find it generally overpriced in our area (why would I spend $14 on a pair of worn out jeans when I can buy a new pair at for that price or less with sales and/or coupons?). But I had to buy some items for my daughter’s Halloween costume a few weeks ago, and we went to Goodwill to find a tank top and some pants that we could dirty/bloody up. Should I have paid full price for new items that we would have then cut up and smeared with dirt and fake blood? That’s just silly. While we were there, we found two adorable dresses that fit her perfectly. Should I have left them behind because we are “wealthy” enough to buy dresses that cost more than $6?

    And coupons? Good grief. Many people are “wealthy” BECAUSE they use coupons to save money. Coupons don’t take money out of anyone’s pocket except for the company that issues them, and their markup is already so high that they can obviously afford to issue coupons at 20-30-40+% off to the general public. You better believe I’m going to use a coupon if one is available!

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, I agree with you.

  13. Bill

    I think it’s crazy to dictate who can or cannot shop there. Living in a free society has so many advantages, but it comes with personal responsibility which you can’t legislate. This reminds me the NYC law, trying to legislate everyone’s health by forbidding vendors to sell soft drinks larger than 16 ounces. People who are “well off” most likely achieved that by making smart personal choices, so who’s to say when they should no longer be able to do that. And that’s also a great point about landfills full of wasted clothing. I’d say encourage everyone to reuse and recycle, but don’t throttle certain people whose good choices have paid off.

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes!

  14. Heather @ bizewife

    I wonder what people have to say about my habit: shopping at thrift stores for both my own wardrobe, but also to resell on sites like Poshmark and eBay. This is a large component of my side hustle and I enjoy doing it. I live in a high wealth area and that means thrift stores generally have a lot of upmarket and luxury merchandise in great condition. I can buy it at a discount and then make great profits on my resale. I do the same thing with some sample sale merchandise.

    The way I see it is that I am offering folks that don’t live here the opportunity to score still-great deals on designer duds. I also am supporting my local thrifts (i.e. HousingWorks), who are putting their proceeds directly into community outreach and improvement. Win win right?

    1. Cody @ Dollar Habits

      That’s awesome, Heather! Definitely a win-win. My wife is looking at doing the same thing.

    2. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Yes, win-win!

  15. Kristin @ The Wayward Home

    I couldn’t agree more, Michelle! Thrift stores should be used by everyone……especially to help save the environment and keep stuff out of landfills. I almost exclusively shop at thrift stores, and sometimes places like TJ Maxx and Ross, and I’ve found such good deals that I can’t imagine paying full price for something ever again. I’m glad you brought up this issue and hope you inspire more people to shop second-hand 🙂

    1. Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

      Thank you!