Should People With High Incomes Be Allowed To Shop At Thrift Stores?

I like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal. In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there…

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Last Updated: January 27, 2025

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you decide to make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. See my disclosure for more info.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for "poor people." Who should be allowed to shop at thrift stores? #thriftstores #savemoney #moneysavingtipsI like thrift stores. I like browsing through lots of different items and trying to find a good deal.

In case you didn’t know, I actually used to work at a secondhand clothing shop called Plato’s Closet, which is a clothing chain that buys and sells gently used clothing for young adults. I worked there for many years, starting as a sales associate and eventually becoming a manager. Due to working for several years at a secondhand shop, I love a good deal, and it’s still hard for me to pay full price for clothing. We saw lots of high-quality clothing and brand name accessories coming in and being sold for a fraction of the price you would see at a traditional retail store.

Buying secondhand doesn’t just save you a ton of money, it prevents waste and lessens the number of things piling up in landfills.

I think we are all aware that we are throwing things into landfills at alarming rates, and shopping secondhand can be one of many ways to make a difference.

However, that’s not how some people see shopping at thrift stores, especially if you have a high income.

I have actually been told that I shouldn’t shop at thrift stores or use discounts (such as coupons), because those are only for “poor people.”

I have been told that by shopping at a thrift store, I am taking items that people with less money could have bought and used.

I’ve also heard that people who shop at thrift stores in order to flip items for a higher profit are “evil.”

Other comments I’ve heard about shopping at thrift stores include (these are all direct quotes):

  • “Why donate if it’s not going to poor people?”
  • “A person isn’t actually wealthy if they shop at Goodwill.”
  • “Shopping at thrift stores is for people who can’t afford clothes.”
  • “The wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money. They should leave it for the less fortunate.”

Personally, I believe that thrift stores and discounts are for anyone to use. Of course, everyone is allowed to have their own opinion, but I would bet that those people don’t really understand the positives of purchasing secondhand or the missions that non-profit secondhand stores have.

Related content:

As you can see from the tweet below, my question generated a lot of conversation – from both sides even!

Here is why I believe anyone should be allowed to shop at thrift stores.

 

Everyone is allowed to save money.

Seriously, every single person should be able to save money if they want. Everyone, period.

Do I need to say it again?

People who think that the wealthy shouldn’t be allowed to save money are just nuts in my opinion.

Plus, as you’ll read below, thrift stores serve many other purposes, such as preventing an overwhelming amount of waste clogging landfills and furthering a thrift store’s mission to help charities and their community.

Thrift stores are usually bursting at the seams with new things to put out, meaning there is no shortage of things to buy.

Thrift stores can save a person a lot of money, and who is to say who can and cannot save money?

The wealthy are wealthy for a reason- many of them know how to manage their money correctly. And, this may include shopping at thrift stores and using discounts/coupons. Many look for realistic ways to save money because they don’t like to waste money if they can prevent it.

After all, you’ll never be wealthy if you spend it all.

There are many ways to save money and grow your wealth, and shopping secondhand can be a small step in gaining financial freedom.

Related content: Why You Should Spend Like A Millionaire- The Frugal and Smart Money Habits of Millionaires

 

It’s environmentally responsible to shop at thrift stores.

Thrift stores usually have an overwhelming number of things. It’s not like you are going to buy 100% of the items in the store – they have thousands upon thousands of items to sell.

When you purchase something secondhand, you are keeping one more item out of a landfill.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, 15.1 million tons of textile waste was product in 2013, with around 85% of that going to landfills.

And, according to the Huffington Post, Americans, on average, throw away 70 pounds of clothing each year.

According to Down To Earth Materials, the estimated decomposition time for clothing and other items are:

  • Leather shoes: 25-40 years
  • Nylon clothes: 30-40 years
  • Cotton: 1-5 months
  • Tin can: around 50 years
  • Plastic bottles: 70-450 years

As you can see, the clothing we wear and other household items we use can have a big environmental impact. By purchasing secondhand clothing and items, we can lower the amount of waste we put into landfills and help the environment well into the future.

With more people shopping at thrift stores, there are even more items that are getting a second “life” and even fewer items ending up in landfills.

Can you just imagine how crazy landfills would be if certain people weren’t allowed to shop at thrift stores? There would be so much trash everywhere!

Related: How Thrift Store Reselling Is Good For The Environment And How To Do It

 

There’s enough for everyone at a thrift store.

For the most part, buying a t-shirt at Goodwill or Salvation Army isn’t going to negatively impact anyone – they have plenty of everything there. In some places, they are actually turning away donations because they have TOO MUCH STUFF.

When we donated about 99% of our belongings to move into the RV, we took a lot of our things to thrift stores, but, surprisingly, a lot of our belongings were rejected because they had too much stuff or too many of a specific item. We actually had to hunt for places that would take some of our stuff.

Most of the things that are sold at thrift shops aren’t going to be life or death for anyone – it’s just stuff, which may be hard for many people to realize now, but it is the truth.

There is plenty for everyone and thrift stores won’t be running out of basic household items and clothing anytime soon.

So, the belief that “rich people are taking away items from the less fortunate” is not realistic – because there’s plenty of stuff for everyone. Like I said, thrift stores are bursting with so much stuff that they are turning donations away!

 

Your money is helping the thrift store’s mission.

Thrift stores like Goodwill and Salvation Army exist so that they can make money and put that money towards the charities they support.

So, more people shopping at these thrift stores can help further their mission of helping the community.

For example, with the money Goodwill makes through selling items at its stores and through donations, they were able to place more than 313,000 people into employment in just 2016. It’s possible that if you took away some of their customer base, they may not have been able to help as many people. They even state on their website:

“When you donate your new and gently used items to Goodwill®, we sell them in our stores or on our online auction site and use the revenue generated to fund valuable employment training and job placement services for people in your community.”

For many non-profit thrift stores, their mission actually isn’t to solely sell clothes at low prices. Instead, their mission is to further improve the community and the people in it. To do that, they need funds, and they raise funds by selling donated items.

So, the more people who shop at these stores (including people who can afford regularly priced stuff) actually help them further their mission.

So, what do you think? Do you think that thrift stores and discounts shouldn’t be used by people who can afford otherwise?


Filed under:

Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Author: Michelle Schroeder-Gardner

Hey! I’m Michelle Schroeder-Gardner and I am the founder of Making Sense of Cents. I’m passionate about all things personal finance, side hustles, making extra money, and online businesses. I have been featured in major publications such as Forbes, CNBC, Time, and Business Insider. Learn more here.

Like this article?

Join the Conversation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Liz Eastlake

    Makes no sense for anyone to judge how much money you “should” spend based on income, or even how much you “should” earn. Not their business!

    As far as shopping at thrift stores and other discounters, many wealthy people became wealthy by being frugal, and saving before spending. Are healthier habits to cultivate than the high-consumption credit card one, since the latter can become addictive.

    We have some great thrift stores in our area, and they provide essential community services. Not only do they have amazing deals and an array of merchandise at a fraction of original prices, they offer jobs and merchandise for people transitioning from tough situations, and emotional and spiritual support when connected with faith ministries. Competition from private and franchise thrift stores improves merchandise quality and selection . . . makes thrifting even more fun and attractive.

    BTW, The Dollar Tree and Aldi’s are my A-list for thrifting. Many name brands, good selection, awesome deals 🙂

  2. giulia

    Interesting article, I used to buy in thrift store and sometimes I found more choice here instead “normal” shops…in my personal opinion thrift stores and discounts are for everyone!!!

  3. Suzi

    When you even give ear to the argument that “rich people” shouldn’t shop in thrift stores, you quickly come up against the question of how to define rich, and is it an income level or based on what car you drive, the balance in your checking account, net worth? Who gets to decide, anyway? I’m so sick of the shaming for only having what I’ve worked very hard to get.

    My husband works for the Salvation Army, and he is over their thrift stores in our area. The profits from the thrift stores goes to pay for their residential drug and alcohol rehab program–it’s a six-month program with almost 130 total “beds” (with men in one facility, women in another), and it’s crazy expensive to run; all you have to do is imagine how much a 6-month in-house rehab program is through other channels, but then also try to run a profitable retail business with a military hierarchy model. The Salvation Army itself has other charity work that they do as well, and other donations/volunteer work fund those needs. Because hubby is in the thick of it every day, I hear about how there is SO much “product,” and never enough employees and volunteers at the stores to get it all done–and this is especially true with the donations; they get so, so many, and cities are not always nice if they get to be more than can be handled at a time. Thank you so much for bringing this to the forefront. The racks have never been anywhere close to bare at any of the thrift stores in our area, so there is not an issue of scarcity where those in need can’t find the things they need.

    I am happy to shop at thrift stores for ALL the good it does. I’m happy that my saving a buck and keeping an item out of a landfill does so much MORE than that.

  4. Tiffany|Odd Moms Club

    My life would be over if I were banned from thrift stores! It’s a form of self-therapy for me. And I love the thrill of the hunt! Yes, I could go to the mall and pay the 200% markup (literally) but why would I? I’m being smart and frugal and good to myself, and that’s a position I will always defend. And for the naysayers, those who shop at thrift stores usually are the ones who donate most to thrift stores….see how that works??? We pay it forward and keep the cycle going!

    Loved your rant! 🙂

  5. Damn Millennial

    Haha this is America of course they should be allowed. Maybe it should actually be that those with a low income are not allowed to shop at expensive stores as to not harm their financial well being…

    1. Samantha

      YES! That’s what I was going to suggest. Let’s ban “poor people” from expensive shopping malls. After all, they “shouldn’t” be spending all their income on brand new designer clothing, right? Save that stuff for the Richies who can afford it.

  6. Pam

    I love goodwill and thrift stores. I think anyone should be able to shop regardless of their income. Just because I am smarter with my money, I shouldn’t be penalized.

  7. Joe @ Paper Stackers

    I remember back in college I would always check out our local thrift shops! Not only would it be great for finding quirky clothes for themed mixers, there were some gems in there that I could never find in ‘normal’ shops. I found all kinds of awesome stuff from cheap blazers to retro jackets to nice button downs.

    Sometimes people tried to shame me for shopping there, but I kind of had the same mindset you do – it helps their business which, in turn, helps those less fortunate.

    Great post!

  8. George Chen

    70-450 years? Guess it will be smart to start investing in secondhand plastic bottles. They’re obviously not fading any time soon. 😉

    Poor humour aside, thank you for the article. I agree with you that discounts are for everybody. If some rich guy/lady wanted to buy the faded 5-year-old denim jeans, over the pair that’s made from Antartican Elephant harvested under a full moon and save a hundred bucks, then all the more power to them. It’s their money, they do them and you do you.

  9. Holly

    What a strange thing for people to even think! There are many millionaires who still use coupons and haggle deals on their utility bills! I probably would too!

    I recently heard of a used clothing shop for people who literally cannot afford clothing for themselves or their children. If someone who is not in need were to “shop” there, yes I would find that totally inappropriate and wrong. Don’t take a hand out unless you really need it – basically.

  10. Anita

    The stuff at the thrift store isn’t cheap, because government pays the shops to sell shiny new things to the poor.
    Then it really would be unethical to buy there if you can afford other shops.
    But thrift stores are no social benefit. (? My English isn’t perfect)
    They are just places where you can get rid of all your old stuff without the toil of ebay or a full rubbish basket.
    Its a business for the operator.
    There are some operators who donate the profit, but not all do.

  11. JoeHx

    It frustrates me to no end when people want to discriminate against people with high income or net worth. Yes, anyone should be allowed to shop at thrift stores, for the reasons you put.

    It does seem that there are two reasons people think the rich shouldn’t shop at thrift stores:

    1. Because it makes them look less rich, because what’s the point of being rich if you can’t flaunt it?
    2. Because it’s taking away from poor people and the rich are simply greedy.

    Both, of course, are completely off the mark.

    1. A.Roddy

      Little late but no it’s not off the mark. Rich people can be jerks like anyone else. It shows in our current administration. I would bet 90% rich people are more jerks than poor. As I said I read more upper class wealthy prejudice against poor. According to them poor means lazy. The sanctimonious attitudes here wreaks.

  12. Kimberly Abader

    Thanks for writing this piece Michelle!

    I don’t know what sort of people would say that wealthy people aren’t allowed to shop at thrift stores. That’s just dumb!

    I think it’s a great way to save money, regardless of your financial situation. And wealthy people can shop anywhere they want. In most cases, they worked hard to get to where they are, so they shouldn’t have to spend it only on expensive stuff.

    In terms of the environmental impact, doesn’t it end up in landfill anyway? After we buy stuff from the thrift store and it eventually gets worn out, we’ll throw it away. I think we should be looking more at how we can recycle our goods in general so all produce less waste.

    1. Selena

      From an environmental perspective, shopping secondhand is essentially voting with your dollar. It’s saying I’m choosing to purchase this item that already exists rather than using resources to create a new item. Therefore, if you shop exclusively secondhand you aren’t creating any demand for new stuff.

  13. Jane

    My household income is above average. I am fortunate to live a good life and able to afford many lifestyle choices. One of those lifestyle choices is shopping at thrift stores. No one should judge me for whether I shop at Nordstrom or Goodwill or garage sales…..it’s my business what I do with my time and money.
    I don’t shop for clothing much (that includes at all new and used clothing stores), because I already have more than I need. I buy many household items at the thrift stores and love hunting for items that I need and am able to put to good use.

  14. Masako

    I am an average income earner. I shop at Thrift stores, use coupons and buy stuff on sale so I can afford a nice vacation once a year. Where are how people shop is a matter of personal preference.

  15. Masako

    I do not see anything wrong with
    middle or higher class people shopping at thrift shops. There is no rule stopping lower income people from buying steak and lobster with their food stamps or spending their welfare checks at Nordstrom.